This is not your grandma's cookie, but she'd still approve.
Classic Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
Chocolate Chip M&M Cookie Pie
Old-fashioned Oatmeal Raisin Cookie Pie
Banana Bread Pie
Chocolate Chip Banana Bread Pie
Chocolate Chip Banana Pie
Brookie Cookie Pie (pop-up flavor)
Brookie Cookie Pie (pop-up flavor)
Chocolate Pistachio Cookie Pie (pop-up flavor)
S'mores Cookie Pie (pop-up flavor)
Chocolate Chocolate White Chocolate Chip
MEET THE NEW POP-UP FLAVOR OF THE WEEK!
Too much chocolate? Never heard of her. This Chocolate Chocolate White Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie is packed with rich cocoa and loaded with creamy white chocolate chips. Born to melt in your mouth, it’s tender, chewy, and unapologetically indulgent—hugging every bite like a warm Miami sunset.
Meet our Cookie Pie Baker
Having worn many hats over the years, this was one she never expected to try on. Meet Shoshanna, the proud owner of Cookie Pie Bakery, where sweet surprises become lasting traditions.
It all began with a simple oversight—she was headed to a family dinner and forgot she was in charge of dessert. With little time to spare, she threw together a batch of cookies. Voilà—dessert was served.
Little did she know, those impromptu cookies would steal the show. Her family was instantly hooked, and soon, they were requesting them week after week. What started as a last-minute save became the sweet beginning of something much bigger.
